Review by Gail M. Burns and Larry Murray
Larry Murray: You know how much I have been hoping that Oklahoma! would be the third hit musical this summer, following On the Town at Barrington Stage and Animal Crackers at Williamstown Theatre Festival. I feel like my souffle had all the perfect ingredients and then just as it comes out of the oven, it collapses.
And I ask myself what the hell happened.
Gail M. Burns: Although I like Oklahoma! I was disappointed way back when the BTG announced it as their summer musical. It just seemed such a safe, uninspired choice.
Larry: Well, let’s do a little bit of detective work and see where things might have gone off track. First the music and lyrics by Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II. Oklahoma! is a classic, but even at the 1943 opening, the NY Post critic said the songs were too much alike. And is there any 1940′s song whose lyrics are still the cat’s pajamas?