LIVE: “The Hollow” @ The Theater Barn, New Lebanon [GailSez]

July 18th, 2011, 2:30 pm by Sara

The dreary Gerda (Kathleen M. Carey) and her dashing husband, Dr. John Christow (Patrick White) arrive at The Hollow for a weekend with the Angkatells

The dreary Gerda (Kathleen M. Carey) and her dashing husband, Dr. John Christow (Patrick White) arrive at The Hollow for a weekend with the Angkatells

I am on record as not being much of a fan of the murder mystery genre, but in a surprise twist this past spring I read both a biography of Agatha Christie (1890-1976), and her novel The Hollow (1946) on which the 1951 play of the same name is based. Since I usually see Christie plays with no foreknowledge of the plot, I was disappointed to learn that knowing the denouement ahead of time was a distinct disadvantage. (I know, I know. I hear your chorus of “Duh!”)

But I had rather hoped that having read the novel would allow me to observe and appreciate Dame Agatha’s skill in shifting the story from one art form to another. Instead, I found myself agreeing with Christie’s daughter, who objected to her mother’s decision to dramatize the book, and with Robert Barnard who wrote: “…most of the interest [in The Hollow], unusually, is internal, and difficult to present via Christie’s rather old-fashioned stage techniques.”

In its prose form The Hollow was an Hercule Poirot mystery, but Christie felt she had “ruined” the book by injecting Poirot, and replaced him with a Scotland Yard detective and a local police sergeant in the play. Unfortunately, either she or director Allen Phelps forgot to make them interesting characters.

Post continues below...
Advertisement

Click to read the rest of this story at GailSez.